Mystery Magic

The mesmerizing blend of chocolate, nuts, and secret ingredients. A cookie so magical, you'll make it disappear.

Each batch of Mystery Magic cookies comes with either 12 Regular size (2-ounce) cookies or 6 Large (4-ounce) cookies — choose below.

The more batches you order (any size, any flavor) the more $$ you save.

Plus FREE SHIPPING on orders over $79.

View nutritional details