I have 5 boys and they all loved the cookies! Their responses were: Whoa! These are really good, soo good. They really melt in your mouth. Gooey but not too gooey. Mmmm, delicious.

I was looking for a treat today but didn’t have energy to make cookies and LOVED that I could just pop these in the oven. I love that they’re baked already, so fast and convenient - I’m not worried I’m going to mess them up. I just have to warm them up since the hard part has already been done for me.

I know you already know this, but oh my goodness, these are sooo good!!

These are the best cookies we’ve ever had! We couldn’t choose a favorite, all the flavors were delicious!

Oh man these Mystery Magic cookies are really delicious, gooey, indulgent, all the things. So many flavors that invoked the senses!

Seriously the most amazing cookies!!! I highly considered eating a third one for breakfast this morning!

The cookies were a hit with my family! I’d buy these over crumbl cookies any day of the week.

Okay these are dangerously good!! Perfect texture and flavor right out of my oven.

My wife said to personally tell you guys that these are the BEST cookies she has ever had. My daughter agrees. And my wife is a cookie purist. That is no small feat to be labeled the best.

These are unreal, the best cookies I've ever had! I’m getting some for my family and will spread the word.

Hands down the BEST cookies I've ever had! My kids are already asking me to order more!

These are the BEST cookies I've ever had! I'm not even kidding. I have a huge sweet tooth and these are amazing!